
We cannot demand work-ready graduates while refusing to invest in making them work-ready
Our own research says human capital is the greatest threat to this industry. Then some of us take students for months and pay them nothing.
By Anton Gillis, Chief Executive Officer, HAMAC
I recently spent time at a Cape Town hotel school with the people responsible for training the next generation of South African hoteliers.
I expected a conversation about curricula, graduate competency and practical placements. I left unsettled.
I learnt that some hotels accept students for their practical placements and pay them nothing. No wage. No stipend. No transport allowance. Nothing.
These young people arrive at our properties, put on our uniforms, work alongside our teams, serve our guests and then go home with empty pockets. Let us call that what it is: a transfer of cost from the hotel to the student.
The student still has to get to work. They still have to launder a uniform, pay for transport and eat during a long shift. Those costs do not disappear because the hotel chooses not to carry them. They simply land on a nineteen-year-old and their family.
In South Africa, those costs matter. Commuters who travel mainly by minibus taxi spend a third of their household income per capita on transport alone, against a policy benchmark of ten percent, while fares rose 11.5% between May and June this year. Unemployment reached 33.6% in the second quarter, with five million young South Africans out of work.
Against that backdrop, an unpaid placement is not a neutral administrative decision. It is a barrier to entry.
And it filters for the wrong thing. Not talent, attitude, work ethic or potential. It filters for the ability of a student’s family to subsidise their entry into our industry. That should concern every hotelier.
Tourism supports almost 954,000 direct jobs, roughly one in every eighteen in the country, and ours remains an industry in which somebody can begin in a scullery and, fifteen years later, run a hotel.
That mobility is one of hospitality’s great strengths.
Qualifications matter too. Graduates face unemployment of 12.4%, compared with 39.2% for those without matric. For thousands of young South Africans, education is not simply a certificate. It is the ladder. An unpaid placement removes its bottom rung.
Do that consistently across an industry and, over time, we risk building kitchens, front offices and eventually boardrooms populated not only by those with the greatest potential, but by those who could afford the cost of getting through the door.
And here is the contradiction we need to confront.
When HAMAC surveyed hoteliers for our inaugural South African Hoteliers Report, 77% identified human capital as one of the greatest obstacles to the sustainability of their businesses. Nearly 70% said they were dissatisfied with the competency of the graduates they were hiring.
We say we cannot find enough skilled people. We say graduates are arriving at our hotels without the competencies we need.
Yet at precisely the point where industry has the opportunity to help turn education into practical competence, some operators invest almost nothing in the student. Then we complain about the outcome.
We cannot demand work-ready graduates while refusing to invest in making them work-ready.
A proper placement should not simply provide hours on a roster. It should provide structure. A student should know what they are there to learn. They should receive an induction. They should have a supervisor. They should rotate through meaningful areas of the operation. They should receive feedback and, at the end, a proper evaluation. And they should be paid a reasonable stipend.
Because payment changes the relationship. The student is no longer simply an extra pair of hands. The placement becomes an investment that deserves to be planned, supervised and measured.
Paying a student is not charity. It is an investment in our industry’s future workforce. I understand the commercial pressure. I run businesses too.
Our own research found labour to be the top cost pressure for 37% of hoteliers, while 58% reported profitability as flat or down over five years.
Those pressures are real. But we cannot use the pressure on today’s P&L to justify underinvesting in tomorrow’s workforce. Nor am I arguing that students should be protected from the realities of hospitality. Quite the opposite.
Give them the early starts. Give them the late finishes. Let them experience the pressure of breakfast service, the last table at eleven, the guest complaint and the room that somehow still isn’t ready at check-in.
That pressure is part of the education.
But there is a profound difference between learning resilience on the hotel floor and having to decide whether today’s money pays for transport to work or food.
One builds a hotelier. The other may drive one away.
So my call to fellow hoteliers is simple: pay them.
Every hotel accepting a work-integrated learning student should provide a stipend that, at a minimum, meaningfully contributes towards transport, meals on duty and the upkeep of the uniform required to do the job.
And it should be written into the placement agreement with the institution. Not as a favour, but as a commitment. But individual hotels acting alone will not solve this.
A standard dependent on the conscience or budget of an individual general manager is not an industry standard.
That is why I believe FEDHASA and the TBCSA should lead this conversation and establish an industry-wide minimum student stipend: published, transparent, reviewed regularly against the real costs students face and incorporated into the standards expected of participating members.
A young person should not have to gamble on which hotel happens to value their contribution. Government has set a target of one million direct tourism jobs by 2030. We will not build the workforce required to support that ambition by asking families to subsidise our talent pipeline. These students are not cheap labour. They are our future general managers, executive chefs, housekeepers, revenue managers, entrepreneurs and hotel owners.
Their first experience of hospitality teaches them something far more important than how to check in a guest or turn a room. It teaches them what this industry thinks they are worth. Hospitality has always claimed to be an industry built around people.
If we believe that, then it has to include the young people who chose our industry before our industry chose them.








