
With ever-escalating transport, food, electricity, security, education and medical costs, South African households are stretched to the limit. As financial and related stressors continue to compound, employers are urged to take a hard look at in-office policies to ensure they are justified by the value created and that they are fair to employees, a leadership expert warns.
“Over the past few years, many South African companies have increased their in-office requirements, and some have effectively returned to a mostly in-person, in-office status quo, often without pausing to review whether it pays off for the business, or how it impacts employees. However, rigid attendance rules which don’t serve a clear purpose can erode retention, push up absenteeism and burnout, and have substantial financial implications for individuals. The value of in-office-question therefore deserves an honest assessment,” says Advaita Naidoo, Africa MD at Jack Hammer Global, Africa’s top boutique executive search firm.
THE UNEVEN IMPACT OF RIGID IN-OFFICE MANDATES
The burden of especially full-time in-office mandates is not evenly spread, with junior-to-mid level workers significantly more prejudiced than higher earners, Naidoo says.
“There are most certainly cases where full-time, in-office attendance is desirable and justifiable. However, it would be wise for employers to consider whether and where this approach makes sense, and adjust strategy and policy if and where it doesn’t, particularly where employees simply do their 9-to-5 in office while effectively still working remotely, with little collaboration or in-person interaction.”
Naidoo says full or substantial in-office mandates impact employees across several spheres, including increased costs related to transport and childcare, commuting time, and reduced capacity to manage personal responsibilities.
“These costs effectively reduce the real value of a salary. An employee may earn the same amount whether working from home or in the office, but their disposable income and personal flexibility can be materially reduced under a full-time office policy,” Naidoo says.
And inevitably, less senior employees are hardest hit. They often earn less while living further from the office, and have less flexibility to absorb rising fuel, food and childcare costs, or negotiate alternative working arrangements.
“A full-time office policy can therefore place the greatest burden on the employees least able to carry it,” Naidoo warns.
TALENT AND TRANSFORMATION
Naidoo says employers must also consider what rigid attendance policies signal to the labour market. In a competitive talent environment, flexibility is no longer a fringe benefit, because for many skilled workers, it is literally a key component of the employment offer.
“Candidates weigh a job offer not only by salary, but by the total cost of accepting it: commuting distance, transport costs, time away from home, childcare needs and control over their working day. A role that appears well-paid on paper may become less attractive once an employee calculates the real cost of travelling to an office five days a week.”
This also has particular implications for gender transformation, as in-office policies can disproportionately affect women with caregiving responsibilities.
“Employers committed to transformation cannot treat workplace design as separate from inclusion. A company that wants diverse talent may find that its office policy filters out capable people who cannot afford or sustain the daily cost of presence,” says Naidoo.
THE VALUE QUESTION
The call for a review of in-office policies is not an argument that offices have no value, nor that remote work is always preferable. It is a call for employers to define the purpose of office attendance and ensure that the policy delivers value.
“There are genuine reasons to bring people together. In-person work can support onboarding, mentoring, complex collaboration, creative problem-solving, client engagement, culture-building and the informal exchanges that help teams function,” Naidoo says.
But those benefits do not arise automatically because someone swipes into a building. They arise when employers deliberately create the conditions for meaningful interaction.
That means designing days around shared work: planning sessions, workshops, mentoring, cross-functional problem-solving, client engagements and intentional social connection. It also means ensuring leaders are present and that employees are not required to commute merely to sit in isolation.
“In-person work should create enough value to justify the cost imposed on employees. If it does, employers should explain that value clearly and, where possible and fair, help carry the cost.”








