Home South Africa News Mbete has no right to speak on behalf of Parliament‚ says DA

Mbete has no right to speak on behalf of Parliament‚ says DA

The Democratic Alliance charged on Saturday that the Speaker of the National Assembly‚ Baleka Mbete‚ had no right to issue a statement on behalf of Parliament “lambasting” the Public Protector.

The statement was in response to a news briefing given earlier this week by the Public Protector‚ Thuli Madonsela‚ regarding the parliamentary ad hoc committee established to consider a report by Minister of Police Nathi Nhleko absolving President Jacob Zuma of having to repay any of the taxpayers’ money spent on upgrades to his private residence at Nkandla.

Madonsela told the media briefing that she stood by her conclusion that Zuma should pay back some of the money. She read a statement that she said she would have presented to the parliamentary committee‚ but which had decided not to invite her to address it.

“I expected Parliament to allow me to be interviewed because that is what I believe is the expectation from the Constitution when public functionaries are involved in decision-making‚” she said. “They should ensure that they exhaust all sources of information that may shed light on the issue they want to decide on. I have information on the issue they are deliberating on and I would like to share that information.”

She said that police minister Nathi Nhleko should have reported to Zuma‚ not to parliament.

“We are witnessing worrying defiant trends‚” she said referring to the failure of some state institutions to implement recommendations by independent institutions.

She said she was concerned that the “safety valve that an office such as ours is meant to provide” was “being eroded”.

“I appeal that we stop personalising matters‚” she said.

In a statement on Friday‚ Parliament stated: “The Public Protector chose to address the National Assembly (NA) and its Speaker through the media instead of arranging direct engagement with Parliament. The reason offered for this unprecedented move to address the NA and its Speaker is not consistent with the Constitution‚ the Public Protector Act and democratic practices which we are used to.

“It is regrettable that the subject matter of the briefing is a matter which is currently before an ad hoc committee legitimately established by a resolution of the NA in performance of its Constitutional obligations. The unfortunate impression created is that the NA is malicious in dealing with matters that fall within its Constitutional mandate and that its sole intention is to discredit the Office of the Public Protector.

“Parliament reaffirms its support for all institutions supporting democracy as they are partners in ensuring observance of the founding principles of our Constitution of accountability‚ openness and responsiveness.”

The statement added that‚ in terms of section 181 of the Constitution‚ institutions supporting democracy‚ of which the Public Protector was one‚ were accountable to the National Assembly and must report on their activities and the performance of their functions to the NA at least once a year.

“This is reinforced by section 8 of the Public Protector Act which also requires the Public Protector to table reports in the National Council of Provinces.

“The assertion that the NA‚ by performing its Constitutional functions of considering a report on the matter once investigated by the Public Protector‚ is acting in contempt of the Public Protector is incorrect and simply flies in the face of the Public Protector Act. Parliament finds it ironic that the Public Protector in her media briefing referred to the Constitution and the Public Protector Act but chose to flagrantly disregard them.

“Parliament wishes to emphasise that‚ as an institution established by the Constitution‚ it has the power to regulate its own internal arrangements. It cannot be dictated to by another institution – including the Public Protector – about how to conduct its business. The Office of the Public Protector can only exercise powers and perform functions given to it by the Constitution and the Public Protector Act‚” the statement said.

It added: “The suggestion that Parliament treats the Public Protector with less respect than other institutions supporting democracy‚ in particular the Auditor General‚ is not supported by any evidence. Parliament reiterates that it treats all institutions supporting democracy in a manner that is consistent with the Constitution. The fact that Parliament established an Office of Institutions Supporting Democracy confirms the seriousness with which it treats these offices.

“Parliament will continue to support all institutions supporting democracy and ensure that they exercise their powers and perform their functions without fear‚ favour or prejudice. Parliament will assist and protect these institutions to ensure their independence‚ impartiality‚ dignity and effectiveness as required by the Constitution.

“Parliament recommits itself to the supremacy of the Constitution and the rule of law. It reasserts its independence as an institution that carries the mandate of the citizens of South Africa.”

Responding to the statement by Parliament‚ DA chief whip John Steenhuisen said: “This move by Ms Mbete is as inexplicable as it is baseless given that she is speaking on a matter that has not yet been resolved by Parliament and is before the Ad Hoc Committee. She released a statement that resembles her remarks in her capacity as the Chairperson of the ANC.

“In fact‚ she could’ve communicated in this capacity or in her capacity as the Speaker of the NA but not on behalf of Parliament‚” Steenhuisen asserted.

He added: “While Mbete is the Speaker of the NA she cannot use her position to further the ANC’s agenda and must be reminded that the National Assembly is made up of 400 members and that any and all communication on behalf of Parliament must be impartial and reflect the sentiments of those members and not use Members of Parliament to legitimise her nefarious party political agenda.

“In the absence of such a resolution she simply has no right to speak on behalf of all Members of Parliament.”

Source: RDM News Wire.

South Africa Today – South Africa News