
JOHANNESBURG, Gauteng — South Africa’s latest crime statistics show a 2.3% decline in contact crime between July and September, with all nine provinces recording overall decreases, but the South African Police Service (SAPS) figures still count 5,590 murders in just three months — a reality that crime analyst Chad Thomas says makes any celebration premature.
The second-quarter results for the 2026/27 financial year point to a broad cooling in violent crime. Murder dropped by more than 1,600 cases year on year, while assault with intent to cause grievous bodily harm, common assault, common robbery and robbery with aggravating circumstances all declined. Sexual offences also fell nationally, although KwaZulu-Natal (KZN), Limpopo and the Western Cape moved against the trend with increases in reported cases.
‘Nowhere near good enough’
Thomas, CEO of IRS Forensic Investigations, said the direction of travel was positive but the baseline remained alarming. Total contact crime moved from roughly 155,000 to 152,000 year on year — a statistically meaningful drop of just over 2%, but, in his assessment, “nowhere near good enough”.
He pointed to a rise in mass murders and mass shootings, and to persistently high levels of gender-based violence and femicide (GBVF), as the clearest signs that the country’s violence problem has not been solved.
At the same time, Thomas pushed back against the impression left by recent oversight hearings that the police are wholly incompetent. Large-scale operations such as Shanela and Prosper have produced arrests running into the hundreds of thousands, he said, evidence of a police service that is “although barely functioning, still functioning nonetheless”. The thin blue line, he argued, is holding — and should continue to hold given the five-point plan announced by the Police Minister the previous day to reset the SAPS over the next three years.
Firearms used in 2,552 murders
Firearms were the most frequently used murder instrument during the quarter, appearing in 2,552 killings. The Police Minister has undertaken to intensify efforts to trace and recover illegal weapons, but Thomas argued that recovery alone will not stop the bloodshed.
Speaking after attending a private security industry awards event the previous evening, he described accounts of security officers and cash-in-transit crews being ambushed by three, four or five vehicles at a time, with attacking groups of 25 to 30 people largely armed with automatic rifles — AK-47s, R4s and R5s stolen from the police or the military.
But theft from state armouries and the private sector is only part of the picture. Thomas said weapons are also flowing in through South Africa’s borders, including Lesotho and Namibia, while explosives cross from Zimbabwe for use in cash-in-transit heists, ATM bombings and zama zama mining.
He cited a raid on a private storage facility in Cape Town, where officers searching for cocaine also discovered weapons that had been smuggled into the country along the same route as the drugs — proof, he said, that established import channels are supplying criminal networks.
The answer, according to Thomas, lies in disruptive operations built on effective crime intelligence: infiltrating syndicates, disrupting their activity and ultimately dismantling them.
Western Cape accounts for about 80% of gang murders
The Western Cape accounts for approximately 80% of gang-related murders, according to the statistics and the Minister’s briefing. Asked why the province has failed to break the cycle despite years of targeted policing and army deployment, Police Minister Firoz Cachalia invoked the legacy of apartheid — an explanation Thomas endorsed.
Apartheid spatial planning still shapes policing, he said, and both traditional townships and newer informal settlements lack the infrastructure that effective policing requires. Informal settlements in particular have virtually no policing presence.
Thomas contrasted this with the mid-to-late 1990s, when PAGAD shifted from a community organisation fighting gangs and drugs towards terror tactics, bombing a café in Sea Point and another in Camps Bay. Crime intelligence infiltrated the group, identified its leadership, reached its pipe-bomb makers and dismantled its operations. That capability, he said, was never expanded, and crime intelligence has since been eroded by capture and under-resourcing.
His conclusion was blunt: crime intelligence cannot be disbanded. It must be capacitated and resourced, because it remains the most important component in fighting organised crime.
Concerns over alcohol and substance abuse, and their link to sexual violence against women and children, remain part of the unresolved picture behind the numbers.








