
JOHANNESBURG, Gauteng — Rape victims are rapidly losing hope in the South Africa justice system due to systemic failures and hostile policing, according to a new research briefing released by Amnesty International. The report highlights that persistent barriers and poor communication within the criminal justice framework are denying survivors the justice they deserve, painting a grim picture of gender-based violence (GBV) response in the country.
While the Department of Justice and Constitutional Development has previously boasted a sexual offenses conviction rate of 74.8%, Amnesty International notes that this figure is highly misleading. The statistic only reflects the outcomes of cases that successfully reach the verdict stage and completely ignores the vast number of cases opened that never progress to prosecution. In stark contrast, a national quantitative study by the Medical Research Council (MRC) indicates that the actual conviction rate for rape cases sits at approximately 8.6%.
Cassandra Dorasamy from Amnesty International South Africa explained that this massive drop-off is due to “rape case attrition”—a phenomenon where cases fall away as they move through the reporting, investigation, and prosecution stages. According to the research, the bulk of this attrition occurs at the South African Police Service (SAPS) level during the initial reporting and investigation phases.
To understand the grassroots reality behind the statistics, Amnesty International conducted in-depth, qualitative interviews with rape survivors. The research was not designed to be statistically representative, but rather to capture the lived experiences of those navigating the system. Survivors interviewed for the briefing were located in KwaZulu-Natal (KZN), the Eastern Cape, Limpopo, and the Western Cape.
The findings reveal a deeply flawed initial response from law enforcement. Survivors reported being met with hostile attitudes from police officers, often being questioned in a manner that made them feel as though they were the perpetrators of the crime. Furthermore, many were not directed to victim-friendly rooms, denying them a safe and dignified environment to share their traumatic experiences.
Communication breakdowns further compound the trauma. Survivors noted that after laying a charge, they frequently received no updates on their case’s progress. When communication did occur, it was often out of the blue, with victims being informed that their cases had been withdrawn or closed without any clear explanation. Dorasamy emphasized that these initial interactions with police profoundly shape a survivor’s entire experience of the criminal justice system, leaving many feeling dejected and entirely hopeless about the prospect of justice.
In addition to speaking with survivors, Amnesty International also interviewed members of the National Prosecuting Authority (NPA) and the judiciary to understand the breakdown in communication and case progression.
The briefing concludes with a comprehensive set of recommendations directed at the SAPS, the NPA, and the National Council on Gender-Based Violence and Femicide. A primary recommendation is for prosecutors and investigators to consult with one another at the earliest stages of a case. This early collaboration is deemed essential to identify potential gaps in evidence, allowing authorities to build stronger, more cohesive cases that can successfully be pursued through prosecution, ultimately ensuring that fewer cases fall through the cracks before they ever reach a courtroom.








