
JOHANNESBURG, Gauteng — The ongoing National Union of Metalworkers of South Africa (NUMSA) leadership fight has escalated to the Johannesburg High Court, where regional leaders have launched an urgent application to seize control of the union’s bank accounts, investments, and overall administration. The legal battle highlights a deepening fracture within the National Union of Metalworkers of South Africa (NUMSA), threatening the governance of one of the country’s largest trade unions representing approximately 300,000 workers.
The power struggle centers on who holds the legitimate authority to govern the union and call a national congress. The current national office bearers, led by Andrew Chirwa and Irvin Jim, are operating with an expired mandate. According to the union’s constitution, a national congress must be held every five years to elect new leadership. However, the transition process has been stalled by protracted litigation and internal infighting.
The conflict reached a boiling point on October 23, when the national office bearers abruptly cancelled a crucial central committee meeting in the final hour. This meeting was intended to finalize the dates for the national congress. In response, regional leaders proceeded with the meeting in the national office bearers’ absence. During this session, the regional leaders resolved to form a coordinating task team and officially suspended the national office bearers, citing constitutional violations, including the failure to convene a national executive committee (NEC) meeting for nearly 20 months.
The national office bearers, dismissing the regional leaders as “rogue elements,” retaliated by suspending them. This mutual suspension triggered a wave of legal action across multiple jurisdictions. Recently, the Labour Court ruled in favor of the Mpumalanga region, allowing its representative, Mr. Nkosinathi Makhanya, to participate in decision-making processes. The Labour Court also dismissed an appeal by the national office bearers regarding the exclusion of Mpumalanga and Natal from previous meetings. Furthermore, the Labour Court ordered the national office bearers to convene an NEC meeting within 14 days, comprising seven days for notice and seven days for the actual meeting.
Despite the Labour Court’s directives, the regional leaders approached the High Court to solidify the coordinating task team’s authority and gain full access to the union’s financial records. They argue that the national office bearers have failed to maintain financial transparency. Adding to the governance concerns, the regulatory registry has reportedly written to NUMSA, demanding that the union update its financial records, ensure transparency, and submit its audits while the litigation plays out.
Presiding over the High Court urgent application, Judge Muhammad has rolled the matter over to Friday. The regional leaders are pushing for a swift resolution, arguing that four out of the nine required regional congresses have yet to take place, making a national congress impossible under the current impasse. Funds were reportedly set aside for these regional congresses as far back as December 2025, but the delays have left the union’s roadmap in limbo.
As the legal battle continues, the 300,000 members of the metalworkers union remain caught in the crossfire. Workers are left waiting to see which faction will ultimately guide the union through its critical transition period and address pressing issues regarding worker safety, security, pay, and Section 189 retrenchments in a dwindling South African manufacturing sector. The High Court is expected to provide clarity on Friday regarding whether the coordinating task team or the national office bearers will wield the power of control moving forward.









