Home South Africa News Federation vs Confederation, the Cornerstone is Sovereign Independent States

Federation vs Confederation, the Cornerstone is Sovereign Independent States

Federation vs Confederation, the Cornerstone is Sovereign Independent States
Andy Winsauer

By definition the difference between a confederation and a federation is that the membership of the member states in a confederation is voluntary, while the membership in a federation is not. Sometimes confederation is erroneously used in the place of federation.

COMPARISON CHART

CONFEDERATION

FEDERATION

Sovereignty

Held by the member states. In a Confederation, the federal government is accountable to the member states, who are the ultimate authority.

Held by the federal government. In a Federation, the federal government will hold the ultimate authority and the member states will be subordinate to it.

Central Authority

The central authority of a confederation is usually a weak body appointed by the member states.

The central authority of a federation is a federal government which governs the member states.

Powers of the Central Authority

Usually will focus on joint foreign policy and defense matters, but rarely will have the power to do much more than that.

Determined by the constitution of the federation, but will generally have rights to exercise control over the diplomatic, military, economic, and legal spheres of the member states

The UNION OF SOUTH AFRICA, imposed on the region by the British colonialists has obviously proved to have been a gigantic error in terms of lumping people of so many different cultures together in a unitary state, entirely without regard for their geographic diversity of cultures within the region, and without taking the “Will of the people” into account.

Many of our grandparents were alive in 1910, which shows just how recently this took place.

During this period, the Union of SA and subsequently the current Republic of South Africa has been governed as a unitary state continuously based on race based policies under both apartheid, and again under the current centrist policies of the tripartheid government made up of the African National Congress, South African Communist Party and the trade unions, only to have been proven to be a massive failure.

Yet, the very foundation of the problem is being ignored by the entire political community, commentators and analysts, namely the delusion of expecting unity from a forced and self serving Union of vastly differing cultures, heritage and desires for self determination across the length and breadth of Southern Africa.

As can be seen from the chart above, a confederation of independent states would be far more preferable to a Federal state which however, seems impossible to achieve in the current South African context. Even partial requests for devolution of at least some powers to provincial level have already been vehemently turned down by national government.

A Confederation theoretically sounds like a great solution.

However, that could only become an option when a series of independent states voluntarily decide to work together in a confederacy.

Simply put, sovereign independence where self determination is sought by the people of a region, can be the only solution for an eventual highly successful Confederation of South African States.

The Western Cape is already very strongly pursuing sovereign independence, with the number approaching 900 000 registered mandates from its citizens seeking a referendum on the question, independence: yes or no?

The Zulu nation, the Venda and a few others too are seeking independence, whereas within the geographical region, Namibia, Lesotho, Botswana and Swaziland are already independent, with nothing stopping them from joining such Confederation of states if they so wished, and if it ever were to become a reality.

The process of forming a Confederation of independent states will no doubt take a very long time to achieve, but the secession from the current unitary state of SA could happen surprisingly quickly, especially for the Western Cape.

It’s inevitable anyway, the question only is, “when?”

That too is simply answered, namely as soon as 50%+1 of the citizens of the WC vote “Yes” in the referendum, the process begins.

The referendum can be called very soon by the premier of the WC in accordance with article 235 of the South African constitution and as soon as the outdated apartheid era law is updated in accordance with the constitution.

The stumbling block is however, the DA’s political ambitions to rule the entire country without addressing the fundamentally flawed system in the first place, hence their futile attempt in pursuit of Devolution of certain powers for the Western Cape, in an attempt to stop their decline in the WC despite the “Will of the people” of the Western Cape where they rule.

Rule the people or Serve the people is another obvious discussion for a later article, or in other words, putting political party ambitions above those of the people they’re supposed to serve.

All eyes yet again on the next elections instead of on a long term view for a prosperous, safe and sustainable future for all the peoples of Southern Africa.

—————————————————————-

Andy Winsauer is a retired director of various leading international Companies based in Austria, Germany, Switzerland, and South Africa, and was until recently director of the largest pro-independence civic movement in South Africa, CapeXit non-profit organisation. He is now an independent commentator.