Home Lifestyle Toxic Masculinity

Toxic Masculinity

By Tshepo Sefotlhelo - Executive Head: Marketing and Communication GBVF Response Fund1 

Toxic Masculinity
Tshepo Sefotlhelo

Dissolving toxic masculinity is key in fighting GBVF – we need to focus on boys unlearning negative perceptions of what it means to ‘be a man’ 

Boys will be boys. How often do we hear that uttered to explain away the dominant or bullying actions of boys on the playground? Or, even in the boardroom? By using these words, we show acceptance of toxic behaviour, implying that boys and men are naturally wired this way, and so really cannot be accountable for their behaviour.  

It is as if we accept that ‘manliness’ is some mysterious force by which men take on the ‘superpowers’ of strength, boldness, bravery and leadership because women, ‘weaker men’, or other vulnerable members of society are emotional and unpredictable.  

Our language bolsters and reflects a ‘manliness’ where sex and aggression equal strength, and where a man’s status as a ‘man’ can be taken away if he shows so-called ‘feminine’ traits of vulnerability or healthy emotion. In such instances, he will be told to “man up”. If we listen to the words we use and hear, and the conversations we have, we realise that we are not dealing with some unspoken code – we use our language to explain and uphold toxic masculinity. 

Men have learned that to be masculine they must be powerful and unrelenting. Their manhood is claimed by taking ownership of things. Money, real estate, social status, and sexual conquests have become the valued commodities that represent power and strength. Power over another, or what sociologists, for years, have termed “dominance behaviour,” is seen as the core characteristic of masculinity.  

Toxicity thrives on and is driven by cultural norms and socialisation based on ideas that masculinity is centred on a man’s control of others, sexual entitlement, inequitable gender attitudes, risk-taking and antisocial behaviour. This is the breeding ground for gender-based violence and femicide (GBVF).  

Alongside this, our families, society and systems of power entrench ideas about femininity that promote the subordination of women (and other vulnerable groups) to men, and submission to violent acts perpetrated by many. 

And so, when we say “boys will be boys” in our patriarchal system, we are breathing life into a socialisation that normalises violence, and GBVF in particular. This toxicity seeps into our institutions and spaces and dictates the way we work and live. It is found in the bloodied body of a young gay activist, killed for being ‘that way’, and in the mind of the little girl who has just been told to wash dishes because playing soccer outside with her brothers is a ‘boys’ sport’.  

Often overlooked, is that this hurts men and boys too. It denies exploration of emotions, it denies the very expression of the spoken words of “I am not ok, I need to talk about how I feel”. It denies access to the ‘old boys club’ for those who do not excel at ‘manly’ endeavours. It hurts the little boy who is told not to tell anyone – ever – that his uncle has just raped him. It hurts the young man who feels the pressure of winning, winning, winning – all the time, at any cost.  

Evidence shows that we need to change the way society thinks about this and how it contributes to GBVF, and rationalises it, if any of our interventions are going to be successful. Social behaviour-change is a huge endeavour, as is changing gender-norms.  

The National Strategic Plan on GBVF provides a roadmap for us to dismantle our patriarchal systems, restore justice, provide survivor support, encourage women’s economic power, and ensure accountability at the highest levels of decision-making and in government. It is also about peeling away toxic masculinity in our workspaces, our faith spaces and our communities. It is about how we divide the labour in our homes and how we love, or dismiss, each other, in the language we use with and about each other. 

It’s important to remember that these unhealthy attitudes and behaviours are rooted in patriarchy and that the terms aren’t interchangeable, but if you want to adopt a medical analogy then patriarchy is the illness and toxic masculinity is a symptom by which a diagnosis can be made. 

Masculinity in and of itself is not toxic. What made this so is the narrowly defined parameters of what it means to be masculine.  

We often hear of boys being raised in a system that promotes aggression, power and rage, where some are encouraged to use anger or violence to solve conflict. They hear phrases like “don’t start the fight, finish it” or “don’t hit first, hit hardest”.  

We often hear or see reports of public figures, some of whom are held up as the sporting or other idols of many boys, accused of harming others, labelling their accusers as “career-killers”.  What message is being sent to our boys? 

It is time for all of us to reflect on this and make the conscious decision to pass on to our boys the value of accepting the differences of others and embracing diversity. We can teach our children how to work together and understand different points of view. We can teach our boys to embrace an attitude of compassion, empathy, kindness, and respect for women and others who are traditionally targets of toxic masculinity, and in many instances, ultimately GBVF. We can succeed in raising our boys to be emotionally healthy masculine men – beginning at home.  

About the GBVF Response Fund1: 

The Gender-Based Violence and Femicide (GBVF) Response Fund1 was launched by His Excellency President Cyril Ramaphosa, in February 2021, to tackle the scourge of GBVF in South Africa. The Fund is a private sector-led initiative aimed at supporting the implementation of the new National Strategic Plan on GBVF, by raising financial and non-financial resources, and allocating them to high-impact organisations working to tackle the prevention of GBVF and ensure support and access to justice for victims. In addition, the Fund pursues impactful public-private partnerships to address GBVF.