There is a particular kind of restlessness in marketing. A new financial year arrives. A new leadership team comes in. The business expands. Consumer behaviour changes. A new technology appears. Suddenly someone asks: Do we need to reposition the brand?
Having spent much of my career moving between consumer insight, brand strategy, creative, commercial marketing and, increasingly, customer and performance growth, I have come to believe we ask this question far too quickly.
Sometimes brands do need to change. Very often, the answer to growth isn’t reinvention. It is deeper ownership. It is identifying the most powerful truth your brand already has permission to own and finding ways for that truth to mean more, to more people, in more moments.
That distinction matters because, in our pursuit of something new, marketers can unintentionally walk away from something far more valuable: memory, meaning and distinctiveness that have taken years to build.
The temptation to confuse movement with progress
Marketing loves novelty. New strategies, platforms, technology, language and campaigns. I’ve seen this across very different categories during my career, from telecommunications and FMCG to restaurants, retail and now ecommerce. I have also sat on both sides of the agency and client relationship.
The context changes, yet one challenge remains remarkably consistent: How do you keep a brand relevant without constantly changing what it stands for?
That question feels particularly important now. Generative technology can create more content, more variations and more iterations, faster than any marketing organisation could have imagined a few years ago. Greater production capacity doesn’t automatically create greater brand value. In fact, when everyone can make more, the competitive advantage increasingly becomes knowing what is worth making.
That requires human judgement, cultural understanding, a strong point of view and, above all, a clear idea at the centre of the brand. Creativity therefore isn’t the decoration we apply after strategy. Creativity is one of the mechanisms through which strategy compounds. Creativity is how strategy compounds in the real world.
A platform should make a business bigger without making the brand fuzzier
We’re confronting exactly this challenge at Mr D. For many South Africans, Mr D has historically been strongly associated with food delivery. Today the platform stretches into groceries and a much broader range of everyday retail needs.
The easy marketing solution would be to spend our energy telling people how many more things they can now buy on the app. That isn’t really a brand strategy. It’s a catalogue.
The more interesting question was: What is the common human benefit that connects all these different occasions?
For us, the answer sits inside something Mr D has always fundamentally delivered: effortless convenience. What has changed is what convenience can mean in people’s lives.
Years ago, convenience might simply have meant not having to cook dinner. Today it can mean something much more emotionally valuable. It is one less thing to remember, one less errand, one less trip to the shops and one less bit of life admin competing for space in an already overcrowded brain.
Dinner after a long day. Done. Groceries when there isn’t time to shop. Done. The pet food you suddenly realise has run out. Done. The thing you’ve forgotten that you need tomorrow. Done.
We don’t need to abandon effortless convenience. We need to deepen what it means.
Build platforms, not campaigns
This is also why I increasingly believe marketing leaders need to distinguish between a campaign idea and a brand platform. A campaign needs to work for a moment. A platform needs to work repeatedly.
It should stretch across products, categories, customer needs, cultural moments and channels without requiring the brand to reinvent itself every six months. That’s the role we want D is for Done to play for Mr D.
Food? Done. Groceries? Done. Everyday retail? Done.
Crucially, D is for Done isn’t merely a device for communicating the breadth of what is available on the app. The bigger emotional promise is having one less thing to think about. It takes Mr D’s longstanding promise of effortless convenience and gives the business’s commercial expansion a single consumer meaning.
To me, that is where strong brand strategy and growth strategy start becoming the same conversation.
Distinctiveness matters even more in an AI world
Having the right strategic proposition isn’t enough. People need to remember that it belongs to you. And in an AI-enabled world, that depth of ownership is going to matter even more.
AI is already transforming how we produce marketing. It will accelerate iteration, increase personalisation and lower production barriers. As more organisations gain access to similar production capability, production itself becomes less of a differentiator. AI doesn’t diminish the value of creativity. If anything, it raises the premium on truly distinctive creativity. Imagination, taste, cultural fluency and distinctive ideas become more important.
At Mr D, the Done, Done, Done earworm isn’t there simply because we wanted a catchy piece of music. It is an attempt to turn a strategic idea into something people can recognise and recall, something capable of travelling across channels and occasions.
We’ve deliberately grounded the creative world around D is for Done in recognisably South African voices, humour, families and everyday chaos. I have learned another lesson over the years: Local isn’t the opposite of scalable. Generic is.
South African audiences are sophisticated. They recognise when brands understand them, and they recognise equally quickly when brands are simply borrowing the language of culture. Real cultural relevance comes from specificity: the phrase someone uses, the family dynamic everyone recognises, the joke that doesn’t need explaining, the music or the tiny observation about South African life that makes someone think, That is so us.
As technology makes technically excellent execution increasingly accessible, I believe human specificity will become more valuable, not less.
Brand and performance are not opposing philosophies
There is one final tension I think marketers need to move beyond: brand versus performance.
I have spent enough of my career across both worlds to believe this is largely a false choice. Performance marketing is extraordinarily good at capturing and converting demand. It becomes much more powerful when there is something distinctive for it to amplify.
Brand creates memory. Creativity creates meaning. Distinctiveness increases the chances that people remember whose message they saw. Performance provides the signals, distribution, experimentation and conversion engine that allows us to turn demand into measurable action.
The strongest marketing systems don’t choose between brand and performance. They allow each to make the other work harder.
A powerful creative platform sits between them. It gives brand building consistency while giving performance marketing different ways to express and activate the same idea.
Before you reinvent, ask a harder question
When a business changes, I don’t think the first marketing question should automatically be: What should our brand become?
There are better questions. What do customers already believe about us? What do we have genuine permission to own? Is there more meaning inside that idea than we have extracted from it? Can it stretch with the ambition of the business? And can creativity make it distinctive enough to belong unmistakably to us?
Sometimes the answer will still be reinvention. Don’t underestimate the power of accumulation. Strong brands are built when distinctive ideas, experiences, memories and associations compound over time.
In a marketing world increasingly obsessed with making more, faster, perhaps one of the smartest things we can do is resist the urge to keep starting again.
Don’t reinvent something valuable simply because you can. Find the truth worth owning. And then go much, much deeper.











