Home Business ISS defeats Bargaining Council’s urgent bid for a gag order over criticism...

ISS defeats Bargaining Council’s urgent bid for a gag order over criticism of workers’ funds

ISS defeats Bargaining Council’s urgent bid for a gag order over criticism of workers’ funds
ISS defeats Bargaining Council’s urgent bid for a gag order over criticism of workers’ funds. Image supplied by PR company.

The National Bargaining Council for the Road Freight and Logistics Industry (NBCRFLI) has failed in an urgent court bid to silence Innovative Staffing Solutions (ISS) and its Managing Director Arnoux Maré over questions raised about the NBCRFLI’s accounting for R2.59 billion in workers’ benefit funds.

The High Court in Johannesburg on Tuesday struck the Council’s application from the roll for lack of urgency and awarded costs against it. The Council had turned to the courts after ISS publicised alarming findings from an independent analysis of the Council’s audited financial statements, prepared by forensic accounting expert Professor Harvey Wainer of the Wits School of Accountancy. The Council has since applied to have the matter enrolled on the ordinary court roll.

The independent analysis raised serious questions about the Council’s accounting treatment of workers’ benefit funds, including why the Council appeared to record R2.59 billion in these funds as its own assets in its financial statements, and apparent shortfalls in three benefit funds between 2021 and 2023.

Following publication of the findings, the Council’s attorneys issued a letter of demand on 29 September, calling on ISS and Maré to retract their comments and issue an unconditional public apology. However, ISS and Maré refused, standing by the findings and maintaining that the concerns raised were based on the Council’s own audited financial statements and were published in the public interest.

The Council subsequently launched an urgent court application, seeking to have ISS’s comments declared defamatory, force ISS and Maré to publish an “unreserved retraction”, and stop them from publishing any further allegedly defamatory statements containing allegations “similar in any respect” to those already raised.

Maré terms the failed application the Council’s latest attempt to avoid answering legitimate questions about its financial reporting.

“This was effectively an attempt to shut down scrutiny of a statutory body that manages billions of rand connected to workers’ benefits. Instead of engaging in legitimate public discourse, the Council attacked the messenger and launched desperate litigation to avoid further criticism,” he says.

Media in Council’s legal crossfire

The attempted restrictions extended beyond ISS’s own public statements. The Council also wanted ISS and Maré to urgently and formally request that independent media platforms remove news articles reporting on ISS’s concerns about the Council’s financial affairs, even though the journalists and publishers responsible for those reports were not named as respondents in its application.

Maré says the implications are deeply worrying. “This move should trouble every journalist, employer, and worker who believes an organisation entrusted with billions of rand in workers’ hard-earned money should be held publicly accountable. Since when does questioning how workers’ money is accounted for justify trying to silence the people asking the questions?

“The Council seems to have spent more energy trying to stop people talking about its financial statements than demonstrating why the concerns raised are unfounded.

“Worse still, this comes after the Council refused to provide its financial statements and stopped publishing them altogether, leaving ISS no choice but to obtain a court order in October 2024 compelling their disclosure.”

Council warns it could be forced to close its doors 

In its court papers, the Council claimed that critical reporting could threaten its continued existence, stating: “By the time matter [sic] is heard, there is a strong possibility the applicant would have suffered huge financial losses and would have to consider closing its doors.”

“That is an extraordinary statement for an organisation insisting publicly that there is nothing concerning about its financial position,” notes Maré. “

“If questions based on your own audited financial statements can supposedly threaten your ability to keep the doors open, then surely the appropriate response is greater transparency, not less. Workers and employers deserve to understand precisely why the Council believes public scrutiny could have such severe financial consequences.”

ISS further argued in its answering papers before the Court that the Council provided no evidence identifying a single employer, employee, trade union, regulator, or investor that had terminated a relationship, withheld payment, or acted against it because of the reporting.

Maré adds that ISS will not be intimidated and will continue raising questions it believes are in the public interest. “The court application may have been struck from the urgent roll, but the underlying questions have not disappeared. Trying to silence those asking them will not make them disappear either.

“If the Council says its reporting is beyond reproach, then it should publish separate audited financial statements for each worker benefit fund, clearly account for how the money is being spent, and explain the discrepancies identified by the independent analysis.

“We also call on the Registrar of Labour Relations and the Department of Employment and Labour again to investigate these concerns and establish whether the Council is meeting its financial reporting and governance obligations. Workers and employers deserve answers.”