Two-thirds of people today get news and information from non-traditional sources, according to an international survey.
A white paper and survey released by Philip Morris International Inc. (PMI) (NYSE: PM) examines the increasing influence of the Fifth Estate on public discourse. Encompassing a vast and diverse range of independent commentators, social media users, content creators, and online communities, the Fifth Estate poses unprecedented challenges and opportunities for established institutions by empowering individuals and citizen-led movements to drive change.
“The Fifth Estate has become a significant societal force that can be leveraged for good or ill,” commented Dr. Moira Gilchrist, Chief Communications Officer, Philip Morris International. “On the one hand, the digital technologies that underpin it enable everyday people to stand up for what matters to them and help drive broad societal action. On the other, this new power centre can favour emotion and ideology over facts, perpetuating polarisation and misinformation. The question facing businesses, regulators, and society at large concerns how we can help steer this emerging force in a positive direction and address the valid concerns being expressed.”
Most people already interact with and rely on content generated by the Fifth Estate. According to the international survey conducted for PMI by independent research firm Povaddo—the results of which are presented in the paper, “Rethink Disruption: The Rise of the Fifth Estate”—two-thirds (67 percent) of respondents get news and information from non mainstream sources.
These sources, the survey shows, impact people’s daily lives. When asked whether they had taken any action based on information or recommendations from Fifth Estate sources, respondents said they “talked to friends or family about something I read” (90 percent), “made an online purchase” (84 percent), “browsed a company’s website” (84 percent), and/or “made an in-store / in-person purchase” (79 percent). Notably, 69 percent reported that they had changed their views about a particular issue based on the information to which they were exposed.
Despite its growing prevalence, the Fifth Estate elicits concerns. Survey respondents stated that individuals and non mainstream media pose a significant risk in terms of spreading misinformation (59 percent), sharing opinions without evidence (53 percent), and lacking transparency on sourcing (50 percent). Many respondents also highlighted its divisive potential, noting significant risks in terms of enabling the spread of radical ideologies (47 percent), exacerbating societal divisions (44 percent), and fuelling cancel culture (40 percent).
“For PMI, embracing the voices of individuals—most vitally, adult smokers—and encouraging a people-centric debate involving policymakers, public health authorities, and civil society is critical to achieving our ambition of a smoke-free future—a future in which cigarettes have been made obsolete,” said Dr. Gilchrist. “The Fifth Estate can accelerate this future by prioritising accuracy and science-based facts to empower those adults who would otherwise continue to smoke to change to better alternatives.”
As shown in the international survey, most people want governments, regulators, and platform owners to support positive change online by improving law enforcement’s ability to investigate and hold to account those who misuse internet platforms, implementing initiatives to improve transparency, and combating the generation and spread of misinformation. Individuals, too, have a role to play by verifying authenticity before sharing content, insisting on sources that fact-check information, and seeking out a variety of opinions to inform their views.
Read PMI’s latest white paper here.
